Skip to content

Law and Government · 6 min read
When an electronic record or signature counts in Philippine law

Offices that want to stop printing often stop at one doubt, whether a file on a server or a signature made on a screen will hold up when someone questions it. Philippine law has answered since 2000, in the Electronic Commerce Act (Republic Act No. 8792) and in the Rules on Electronic Evidence that the Supreme Court approved in 2001. This article explains what those texts say and is not legal advice.

The basic rule is equal standing

The Act applies to any kind of data message and electronic document used in commercial and non-commercial activities (Section 4). Section 7 says electronic documents have the legal effect, validity or enforceability of any other document or legal writing. Section 6 says information is not to be denied legal effect solely because it is in the form of a data message.1

Equal standing has conditions. Where a law requires a document to be in writing, an electronic document meets the requirement if it maintains its integrity and reliability and can be authenticated so that it is usable for later reference. Integrity means the document has remained complete and unaltered, apart from endorsements, authorized changes and changes that arise in the normal course of communication, storage and display.1

There is also a limit. Section 7 states that the Act does not vary the formalities that existing laws require in the execution of documents for their validity.1 Where another law demands a particular form, that law still has to be read.

What makes an electronic signature count

The Act defines an electronic signature broadly. It is any distinctive mark, characteristic or sound in electronic form that represents the identity of a person and is attached to or logically associated with the document, or any method a person adopts with the intention of authenticating or approving it (Section 5).1 A typed name, a drawn signature or a code can all fall within those words. What the law tests is the procedure behind the mark.

Section 8 makes an electronic signature equivalent to a handwritten one if it is shown that a prescribed procedure existed, one the interested parties could not alter. Under that procedure, a method identifies the party to be bound and indicates that party's access to the document, and the method is reliable and appropriate for the purpose. The party had to provide the signature in order to go further with the transaction, and the other party is able to verify it and decide to proceed.1

The Rules add a stricter kind, the digital signature. It is made with a pair of mathematically related keys, a private key that creates the signature and a public key that verifies it, so that a reader can tell whether the right key was used and whether the document was altered afterward (Rule 2).2 Once a digital signature is authenticated, the Rules presume, among other things, that the message has not been altered since it was signed (Rule 6, Section 4).2

Keeping records so they stay good

Section 13 of the Act deals with retention. A legal requirement to keep a document in its original form is satisfied by keeping it as an electronic document, if three things are true. It remains accessible for later reference, it is kept in the format in which it was generated, sent or received, or in a format that can be shown to represent it accurately, and it allows the originator, the addressee, and the date and time of sending or receipt to be identified.1

The same section lets an office use a third party for storage, provided those conditions are met.1 In practice this means a records system should never overwrite a signed document, should keep the time and the sender with every entry, and should be able to open old files years later.

What the law says about government use

Section 27 of the Act speaks to government directly. Departments, bureaus, offices, agencies and government-owned and controlled corporations that require or accept filings, issue permits, licenses or certificates, or collect fees are to accept documents in electronic form, issue permits and licenses in that form, and accept payments and issue receipts through electronic systems.1

For that purpose the section authorizes them to adopt rules, after public hearing and publication, that specify the manner and format of filing, the type of electronic signature required where a document must be signed, and the control processes that ensure integrity, security and confidentiality.1 The section points an office toward a written rule of its own that says which electronic documents and signatures it accepts.

The Ease of Doing Business law of 2018 goes a step further. It allows electronic signatures on government documents, with adequate security and control mechanisms, and tells agencies to develop, when applicable, electronic versions of licenses, clearances, permits, certifications and authorizations with the same level of authority as the signed hard copy (Section 9).3

If the record is questioned

The Rules on Electronic Evidence, as issued in 2001, apply to civil actions and proceedings and to quasi-judicial and administrative cases. They treat an electronic document as the functional equivalent of a paper one, and they regard a printout or other readable output that is shown to reflect the data accurately as an original (Rules 1, 3 and 4).2

The person who offers an electronic document has the burden of proving that it is authentic. For a private electronic document, this can be done by evidence that it was digitally signed, by evidence that other authorized security procedures were applied, or by other evidence showing its integrity and reliability to the satisfaction of the judge (Rule 5).2

How much the record is believed is a separate question. Rule 7 lists what a court may weigh, including the reliability of the way the document was generated, stored or communicated, the reliability of the way its originator was identified, and the integrity of the system in which it is kept. Records made by electronic means at or near the time of the event, and kept in the regular course of an activity, are excepted from the hearsay rule when the custodian or another qualified witness testifies to this (Rule 8).2

What an office in the Bangsamoro can do

Read together, these texts ask about the care behind a record more than the technology used. A file is as strong as the office's ability to show who made it, when, and that it has not changed since.

We think four habits follow for any office that wants paperless records to hold. Give each person an individual account, so that every action has a name, and keep a log of who did what and when, which ordinary users cannot edit. Store signed documents so that any later change is visible.

Write down the procedure and follow it every time, because a regular practice is what a custodian will later be asked to describe. For documents with special legal formalities, ask counsel before going paperless.

Sources

  1. Republic Act No. 8792, Electronic Commerce Act of 2000. The Lawphil Project, Arellano Law Foundation, 2000-06-14.
  2. A.M. No. 01-7-01-SC, Rules on Electronic Evidence. Supreme Court of the Philippines, text hosted by The Lawphil Project, Arellano Law Foundation, 2001-07-17.
  3. Republic Act No. 11032, Ease of Doing Business and Efficient Government Service Delivery Act of 2018. The Lawphil Project, Arellano Law Foundation, 2018-05-28.
#LawandGovernment#BARMMTech#MoroTech
Share