Skip to content

Law and Government · 6 min read
What the Bangsamoro Organic Law lets the region digitalize

A ministry or a town hall that wants to put a service online soon meets a practical question. Who decides how this is done, the Bangsamoro Government in Cotabato City or an agency in Manila? Most of the answer is in the Bangsamoro Organic Law, Republic Act No. 11054, approved on 27 July 2018. This article explains what the parts of that law that matter for digital public services say, and it is not legal advice.

A list of powers and a rule for the rest

Article V is the center of the law. Section 2 lists fifty-five matters over which the Bangsamoro Government exercises authority, under the general supervision of the President. Several of them are the daily material of government software: administrative organization, budgeting, civil service, business name registration, education and skills training, health, science and technology, and the registration of births, marriages and deaths, with copies furnished to the Philippine Statistics Authority.1

Section 1 of the same article gives the rule for everything else. All powers, functions and responsibilities not granted to the Bangsamoro Government by the Constitution or by national law are vested in the National Government.1 So the first step in planning a system is to find the matter in the Section 2 list. If it is there, the Parliament may make laws on it, and if it is not, a national rule probably governs.

Section 3 adds that the Bangsamoro Government holds the powers expressly granted, those necessarily implied, and those necessary for efficient and effective governance. Article IX, Section 21 commits it to prioritize the acquisition, adoption and application of science and technology for development.1 The law does not name a computer system, but we think it leaves room to build one for a listed power.

Parliament, its records and the budget

Article VII vests the powers of government in the Parliament, which may enact laws on matters within the competencies of the Bangsamoro Government. The same article creates duties about records, and the presiding officer must assure public access to the proceedings of the Parliament and its committees (Section 24). The Parliament must keep a Journal and a record of its proceedings (Section 26). The Speaker must send certified true copies of all approved laws and resolutions to the President and to Congress within ten working days (Section 25).1

The budget rules are just as specific. No public money may be spent without an appropriations law that clearly defines its purpose, and the Parliament prescribes by law the form, content and manner of preparing the budget (Article VII, Sections 27 and 28). Article XII says funds are to be spent in a programmatic, transparent, performance-based and phased manner, and that the annual appropriations law sets performance standards and targets for each sector (Sections 1 and 19).1

Article XII also names who checks the books. The Commission on Audit is the exclusive auditor, and the Bangsamoro Government must have transparency and accountability mechanisms consistent with open government practices (Section 2). Section 40 adopts a policy of full disclosure of the budget, finances, bids and public offerings.1 Each of these duties is a record that has to be produced, kept and shown, which is work software does well.

Authority over local governments

Article VI, Section 10 guarantees the authority of the Bangsamoro Government to regulate the affairs of its constituent local government units, under the Organic Law and a Bangsamoro local government code enacted by the Parliament. The same section protects local governments: the privileges they already enjoy under the Local Government Code of 1991 and other existing laws may not be diminished.1

The full disclosure policy in Article XII, Section 40 reaches local governments too. The Bangsamoro Government is to provide protocols for local authorities, which include posting the Summary of Income and Expenditures and the participation of civil society representatives in the budget process.1 We read this as a basis in the Organic Law itself for a regional system of local finance reports.

Telecommunications is shared

It is common to hear that telecommunications is a national matter. The text is more exact than that. Article XIII, Section 39 gives the Bangsamoro Government authority to grant regional franchises, licenses and permits to telecommunication utilities whose frequencies are confined to, and whose main offices are located within, the region. It also has authority over certificates of public convenience and necessity for telecommunication companies in the region, their registration, and quasi-judicial powers over their operation under rules of procedure set by the Parliament.1

The same section says this does not limit the power of Congress to grant national franchises in the region.1 National law continues to apply as well. The Public Telecommunications Policy Act covers all public telecommunications entities in the Philippines, makes the National Telecommunications Commission its principal administrator, and requires a franchise before anyone operates as a public telecommunications entity (Sections 2, 5 and 16).2 On our reading of Section 39, a carrier that works across the country does not fit the description of a regional utility, and its franchise remains a matter for Congress.

National laws a regional system still follows

Some national laws apply to a system because of what it does, wherever the office sits. The Data Privacy Act applies to the processing of all types of personal information and to any natural or juridical person involved in it, and it makes the head of each government agency responsible for securing the sensitive personal information the agency keeps (Sections 4 and 22).3 A Bangsamoro records system that holds names, birth dates or health data falls within that scope, subject to the few exceptions the Act lists.

Service standards are a second example. The coverage clause of the Ease of Doing Business law names all government offices and agencies, including local government units.4 National information technology policy is a third. The law that created the Department of Information and Communications Technology makes it the primary policy and planning entity of the Executive Branch for the national agenda in this field, with the task of providing an integrated framework for e-government systems (Sections 5 and 6).5

The Organic Law itself keeps some regional rules tied to national ones. A Bangsamoro civil service law must be in accordance with national laws, and national civil service rules prevail in a conflict (Article VII, Section 39).1

What an office in the Bangsamoro can do with this

Before a system is designed, an office can write down three things. The first is the power it rests on, by article and section. The second is the Bangsamoro law or code that sets the details. The third is the list of national laws that follow the data, starting with privacy.

We think this short note belongs at the front of every project document. It tells the builders which rules are fixed and which the office may decide for itself, and it saves a costly redesign later. Where the reading of a provision is uncertain, the office's own lawyers should settle it before any code is written.

Sources

  1. Republic Act No. 11054, Organic Law for the Bangsamoro Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao. The Lawphil Project, Arellano Law Foundation, 2018-07-27.
  2. Republic Act No. 7925, Public Telecommunications Policy Act of the Philippines. The Lawphil Project, Arellano Law Foundation, 1995.
  3. Republic Act No. 10173, Data Privacy Act of 2012. The Lawphil Project, Arellano Law Foundation, 2012.
  4. Republic Act No. 11032, Ease of Doing Business and Efficient Government Service Delivery Act of 2018. The Lawphil Project, Arellano Law Foundation, 2018-05-28.
  5. Republic Act No. 10844, An Act Creating the Department of Information and Communications Technology. The Lawphil Project, Arellano Law Foundation, 2016.
#LawandGovernment#BARMMTech#MoroTech
Share